Hard cases for TX

[wholmeswa]

Been reading the reviews and it appears T5 hard cases should fit the TX. Can anyone confirm?

Thanks in advance.

Wayne

[Tam Hanna]

erm, I can only confirm one thing.

Proporta's soft case fits the Zodiac really nice, and also fits an extended T3. Thus, a T5 and probably also a TX will fit in nicely!

[rlc7254]

The Palm site, when you are buying online, asks if you want any hardware or software items with your purchase as part of the check out, and show you the items. They list all the Palm cases for the T5 as option for the T|X.

:D

[Zano2004]

I can confirm that is correct. I have a hard case (not by Palm) for my T5 that fits my new TX. The stylus also fits. The T5 and TX sure appear to be the same size to me. I've seen photos that show that the TX is thicker, but I can not see that.

[this_way_up]

wahoo not I can have 3 x 2 gb SD on me!!!!!
gonna get another case with 2 sd slots built in like my current one.

[Paraba]

Yes.. T5 and TX have a similar form factor. Look at this link for fit http://www.fortte.com/scr/showcategory3.php/57
Although we have to wait and see if Palm releases a new cradle specifically for this model. Peter

[AndyMac]

Although we have to wait and see if Palm releases a new cradle specifically for this model. Peter
Yeah, right.... They still haven't released one for the LifeDrive. I am using the T5 cradle I bought for the Lifedrive which works great for the TX.

[snark]

The black T5 aluminum case from Covertech is georgous. I can't wait to receive it as I ordered it this weekend!

http://www.covertecstore.com/photos/produits/MC82-01_prod.jpg

[jmccullough]

Very sharp! I want this.

Are you putting a TX in this? I'll be interested in how the black case looks against the maybe black/maybe blue TX.

[snark]

Are you putting a TX in this? I'll be interested in how the black case looks against the maybe black/maybe blue TX. Yes, I'll put a TX in it http://www.1src.com/forums/images/smilie/images/smilies/cool.gif .
I'll post some pictures when I get the case, hopefully end of this week.

[ebrichter]

has anyone used the brando workshop case for the t5? i like a 'book' style case and this one looks good but seems to try to pack a lot in there.
also..and a bit off the thread...any better-than-average screen protector brands out there? i'm going from a t/t to a tx (if i can ever find a brooklyn store that actuallyh has one in stock this week) so i have a lot of bits-and-pieces switching to do.

[alexasha]

The black T5 aluminum case from Covertech is georgous. I can't wait to receive it as I ordered it this weekend!

http://www.covertecstore.com/photos/produits/MC82-01_prod.jpg

Let us know where you will order it from. So far google
search did not produce much results.

[snark]

Let us know where you will order it from. So far google
search did not produce much results. From the Covertec Store (http://www.covertecstore.com) http://www.1src.com/forums/images/smilie/images/smilies/wink.gif but they don't show up on the US site. They do on the UK site though.

[alexasha]

From the Covertec Store (http://www.covertecstore.com) http://www.1src.com/forums/images/smilie/images/smilies/wink.gif but they don't show up on the US site. They do on the UK site though.

Thanks. Actually they do show this case on US site to T5. There is nothing yet for Tx. I have compared T5 and Tx in the store and I throught that Tx was thinner.

[snark]

Thanks. Actually they do show this case on US site to T5. There is nothing yet for Tx. I have compared T5 and Tx in the store and I throught that Tx was thinner. I compared them both side by side and they're identical. If the TX is thinner, it's by a very small margin.

[ebrichter]

i think i've made my decision and am going with the proporta case - but i'd surely like to hear from anyone with positive or negative feelings about it. i really like the book style case. i also like the idea that the buttons aren't covered up by little pieces of leather straps like other ones.

thanks.

[minimalposter]

I am leaning towards the proporta case although I have decided whether I like the book or flip case better. The best feature for me was also that the buttons are not covered -- it really is a minimalistic case when opened.

Please post your thoughts when you recieve your case!! Thanks.

[Tam Hanna]

Here is a review of the Proporta Soft case:
http://tamspalm.blogspot.com/2005/10/palm-easy-carrying-case-for-palm.html

[ebrichter]

I am leaning towards the proporta case although I have decided whether I like the book or flip case better. The best feature for me was also that the buttons are not covered -- it really is a minimalistic case when opened.

Please post your thoughts when you recieve your case!! Thanks.

i did order it - don't quite know where it's being shipped from - so i'll let you know when it gets here. i have liked the book style better - because i'mnot comfortable with my cards and sometimes, my credit cards being 'flipped' upside down while i use my palm. too easy to have them drop out. this seemed like the nicest leather book style case i could find that didn't also have tons of leather straps all over the buttons. i hope it's what i want.

and also waiting for my tx to be delivered..hopefully by friday!

[snark]

I got my Covertec back alu case this morning. It's great and it looks good too.

2 pics:
http://img357.imageshack.us/img357/8056/dscn05041hm.th.jpg (http://img357.imageshack.us/my.php?image=dscn05041hm.jpg)http://img357.imageshack.us/img357/4782/dscn05031ha.th.jpg (http://img357.imageshack.us/my.php?image=dscn05031ha.jpg)

[kealaq]

I am using the Palm-branded "Tungsten" hard case (for the T5) with my new TX. Fits perfectly.

[michbeck]

The Covertec case looks great!
Could you tell me something about the Wifi-quality of the TX when it ist into the case? In my flat the wifi-signal isn't very good, i need every little bit I can get. I hope the Metalcase is not a filter for the wifi-signal...

[Guatiao]

I got the Rhinoskin aluminum T5 case, and it's an almost-perfect match, could be a millimeter or two thinner to have a snug fit. But it looks nice, if only for the Rhinoskin stamped-metal logo up front.

[prhammer]

i did order it - don't quite know where it's being shipped from - so i'll let you know when it gets here. i have liked the book style better - because i'mnot comfortable with my cards and sometimes, my credit cards being 'flipped' upside down while i use my palm. too easy to have them drop out. this seemed like the nicest leather book style case i could find that didn't also have tons of leather straps all over the buttons. i hope it's what i want.

and also waiting for my tx to be delivered..hopefully by friday!

I notice from the pictures that the proporta case uses the same side rail system to attach the TX as the cover which comes with the TX. I'm wondering if this causes any problems since the PDA isn't secured on both sides to the case. Does it have any tendency to flop around?

[Brjlk]

Been reading the reviews and it appears T5 hard cases should fit the TX. Can anyone confirm?

Wayne

What's the advantage of a hard case over a soft one?

John

[jmccullough]

I have generally felt that the hard case gives more protection, although I haven't seen empirical evidence to support that. In addition, the hard cases seem to be much less bulky, so that they can fit in smaller pockets. Finally, if the aesthetics matter to you, you get more of a "high tech" look with the metal case. (That, of course, is a matter of taste; I've seen some very nice looking leather cases.)

I'd be interested in whether anyone is aware of any evidence on the relative protection hard and leather cases provide.

[prhammer]

I have generally felt that the hard case gives more protection, although I haven't seen empirical evidence to support that. In addition, the hard cases seem to be much less bulky, so that they can fit in smaller pockets. ...

It would appear that the Proporta leather case, which has an aluminum insert in the front, is an attempt to blend the strength of the hard case with the look and feel of leather. But I can also see the value of keeping it small for small pockets.

I had a clear plastic case for my Zire 72 (until it was stolen in a burglary of my church office!) and it was a nice touch because you could look at your calendar and such without opening the case. But, invariable I would go to look at my calendar and there would be an alarm on the screen that required opening to cancel it. Also, the clear plastic became rather scratched up after a couple months of use.

I'm still trying to determine the perfect balance of form and function. I like the feel of leather, the compact size of aluminum or clear plastic - tough choices.

[ebrichter]

i couldn't decide which case would be best and i ordered (in my haze late at night!) both the proporta leather book with alum. case (i'm unsure about that hinge for holding the t/x) and the covertec red flip case (i couldn't resist the red case.) so i'll report on my findings when they show up.

[minimalposter]

Eileen -- I am betwen those exact two cases so please post your impressions. I really like the way the proporta case uses the side hinge, but I am worried that it will be too bulky and that the strap will get in the way (they really should have put the strap on the other side). Pictures would be nice ;)

I hope you love both cases!

[Brjlk]

i couldn't decide which case would be best and i ordered (in my haze late at night!) both the proporta leather book with alum. case (i'm unsure about that hinge for holding the t/x) and the covertec red flip case (i couldn't resist the red case.) so i'll report on my findings when they show up.

Esthetically, hinge on left gives a nice book like appearance Which hinge is etter functionally?

The Palm leather case also looks nice: http://store.palm.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1869317&cp=1157586.1963476&parentPage=family

John

[mozambique]

Can anyone tell me how well an aluminum hard case will work with the Palm Universal Keyboard? Is it easy to remove the TX from the case if you want it out, and is it easy to use the palm while in the case? I really like the protective flap cover that flips easily behind the Tungsten series and wonder how much I would like the aluminum case for daily use. I would like the storage for the SD cards.

Thanks

By the way, what are your favorite cases? I've never purchased a Palm case. I am doubting I will now that I have the TX. I just don't like the extra bulk in my pocket. Any sugesstions that would keep the bulk from growing and allow me to use my TX as quickly and effectively as I do without the case?

[prhammer]

i couldn't decide which case would be best and i ordered (in my haze late at night!) both the proporta leather book with alum. case (i'm unsure about that hinge for holding the t/x) and the covertec red flip case (i couldn't resist the red case.) so i'll report on my findings when they show up.
Eileen:
Have you received these cases yet? Which did you end up preferring? These are the two in which I am most interested so I was hoping your first hand review would help me decide. :D

[ebrichter]

Eileen:
Have you received these cases yet? Which did you end up preferring? These are the two in which I am most interested so I was hoping your first hand review would help me decide. :D

i received the covertec red leather flip case 2 days ago (sorry, i've been dealing with a sudden medical issue so haven't been here much). i have to tell you: AMAZING. really perfectly made and just what i wanted. top quality leather and padding. the straps that hold it in are firm but don't obsure any button. all the holes are perfectly cut out. i wasn't going to go with a flip case but i love this one for the feel and very much for the red color! and it came very very fast.

proporta: still haven't received it. will prob. send it back now.

[DaveSebring]

I am dissapointed with all of these case's so far.

It seems that none of the designers actually USE them, because if they did they would find that most ANY case that has ANYTHING (stiches, edges, logo, SD card holder) on the inside of the cover that goes next to the screen WILL SCRATCH THE SCREEN.

I have had and tried many case for Palms and PPC'S and the whole idea of a case IMO is so you can put it in a pocket. All of these case's (except Titanium hard case) will FLEX in your pocket and guess what happens... the "stiches, edges, logo, SD card holder" whatever is opposite the screen will make contact with the screen and RUB.

In my experiance, unless it's in a rigid Titanium like hard case (a brick in the pocket) the screen WILL get scratched.

[ebrichter]

I am dissapointed with all of these case's so far.

It seems that none of the designers actually USE them, because if they did they would find that most ANY case that has ANYTHING (stiches, edges, logo, SD card holder) on the inside of the cover that goes next to the screen WILL SCRATCH THE SCREEN.

I have had and tried many case for Palms and PPC'S and the whole idea of a case IMO is so you can put it in a pocket. All of these case's (except Titanium hard case) will FLEX in your pocket and guess what happens... the "stiches, edges, logo, SD card holder" whatever is opposite the screen will make contact with the screen and RUB.

In my experiance, unless it's in a rigid Titanium like hard case (a brick in the pocket) the screen WILL get scratched.

i don't understand this. the second i take a new palm out of the case, the first thing i do is to put a screen protector on it. problem solved.

[minimalposter]

I am dissapointed with all of these case's so far.
Actually I am a tad disappointed as well. I have used a case with my last three PDAs but I am considering going naked with the T|X

It seems that none of the designers actually USE them, because if they did they would find that most ANY case that has ANYTHING (stiches, edges, logo, SD card holder) on the inside of the cover that goes next to the screen WILL SCRATCH THE SCREEN.
This is the thinking of the proporta alu leather case. The SD cards are on the back/under the device.

I have had and tried many case for Palms and PPC'S and the whole idea of a case IMO is so you can put it in a pocket. All of these case's (except Titanium hard case) will FLEX in your pocket and guess what happens... the "stiches, edges, logo, SD card holder" whatever is opposite the screen will make contact with the screen and RUB.

In my experiance, unless it's in a rigid Titanium like hard case (a brick in the pocket) the screen WILL get scratched.

Again the proporta alu-leather case has a titanium insert in the front flap of the leather case. This would be my case of choice although it looks bulky (and no one has been able to post a personal review) and I do not see a cut out for the speaker.

[minimalposter]

i received the covertec red leather flip case 2 days ago (sorry, i've been dealing with a sudden medical issue so haven't been here much).

Sorry to hear about your medical issues. My thoughts are with you!



It is good to hear you like the convertec case. Do the convertec straps cover the edge of teh 1st and fourth hard buttons? I still think the proporta was a great idea that just wasn't executed.

[ebrichter]

It is good to hear you like the convertec case. Do the convertec straps cover the edge of teh 1st and fourth hard buttons? I still think the proporta was a great idea that just wasn't executed.

no...they are just around the edges of it and you can press them at will.

[redriderback]

I have the above Covertec case:

- it fits my TX perefct!
- it is very, very well made
- the holders for 2 SD cards are way cool
- the case is not really black! But the Palm isn't black too.

Over all: HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

[DaveSebring]

i don't understand this. the second i take a new palm out of the case, the first thing i do is to put a screen protector on it. problem solved.


Hate em. Won't use them, they make my Palm look ugly and feel ugly.

Can't get the things on straight, always get bubbles, feels like I'm going to RIPP the screen off trying to take them off....

Also I am sure that the adhesive leaves a residue that will attract dust and make the stylus stick.

YMMV

[ebrichter]

Hate em. Won't use them, they make my Palm look ugly and feel ugly.

Can't get the things on straight, always get bubbles, feels like I'm going to RIPP the screen off trying to take them off....

Also I am sure that the adhesive leaves a residue that will attract dust and make the stylus stick.

YMMV

pick your poison, i guess. scratched but 'beautiful' palm or clear protector sheet and no scratched screen. i get mine on easily and once in a blue mood have to deal with a bubble.

[ebrichter]

. i get mine on easily and once in a blue mood have to deal with a bubble.

bahahahah...i made myself laugh. once in a blue moon, i meant. blue mood is me in general these days. but now i'm laughing. take what you can get.

[minimalposter]

I spent a good half hour getting my new Boxwave Crystal screen protector on my new T|X. First I steamed up the bathroom to get rid of floating lint. Then I scrubbed my T|X and screen (lightly but through) with the provided cloth. I used the scotch tape over the finger tip not to get finger prints on the screen or protector. I swear Boxwave are the easiest to apply -- but it still takes a lot of maneuvering. The end result is my best application yet ;). Well worth the thirty minutes IMHO

[jough]

Regarding the Covertec black hard case: do you have to slide the T|X into it using the rail system on the left or can it be popped in and out of the case easily?

I tend to use my Palm outside of any case, and like to be able to drop it into or take it out of the case in less than two seconds.

I really miss my old Vx Palm leather slip case - it just had a simple velcro flip top and a belt clip and was small and protective enough, while letting me slip my Palm in and out of it quickly.

[StuGib]

Regarding the Covertec black hard case: do you have to slide the T|X into it using the rail system on the left or can it be popped in and out of the case easily?

I tend to use my Palm outside of any case, and like to be able to drop it into or take it out of the case in less than two seconds.

I really miss my old Vx Palm leather slip case - it just had a simple velcro flip top and a belt clip and was small and protective enough, while letting me slip my Palm in and out of it quickly.

I was just about to order the Covertec black aluminium case when I saw your post - I did a search for slip cases and came up with www.thepouch.com or www.thepouch.co.uk for Europe. Black neoprene case with hard flip cover for $30/£20. Never tried one and can't find any reviews but the form factor is tempting me, though not being able to carry SD cards is a downside.


Edit: The TX version has a page of its own at http://www.thepouch.com/palm-tx.html It does have a velcro-fastened pocket at the back for memory cards, plus a belt buckle (yuck IMO). Not sure how the flap attaches to the body if at all - I've e-mailed them to ask.

Stuart

[redriderback]

The Covertac Hard Case uses NO rail system.
The Palm is securily hold by two aluminium flaps on the left and on the right.

Please refer to picture:

[jough]

So the T|X slides in from the top? I'd be worried about the flaps scratching the finish, but as long as it's fast and easy to get it in and out then I'm sold.

And if the front cover completely flips around to the back so that the Palm can lay flat on a desk (or sit comfortably in my hand), then I probably wouldn't be worried about getting it in and out of the case either.

Do the SD cards actually touch the screen when they're secured there? It looks like they're meant to fit inside the display bezel. Yikes.

[redriderback]

Yes, case slides in from top. The flaps have the same neopren cover as the entire case. In and out is easy. The Sd cards don't touch anything. You could put some business cards into that case too (2-5 pcs.).

[snark]

So the T|X slides in from the top? I'd be worried about the flaps scratching the finish, but as long as it's fast and easy to get it in and out then I'm sold. Yes, the TX slides from the top. The bottom of the flaps is covered also with "neoprene" so it cannot scratch the case.

And if the front cover completely flips around to the back so that the Palm can lay flat on a desk (or sit comfortably in my hand), then I probably wouldn't be worried about getting it in and out of the case either. The front cover doesn't flip around the back. But the back part of the case can lay flat on the desk without moving. As far as sitting in the hand, it doesn't bother me too much.

Do the SD cards actually touch the screen when they're secured there? It looks like they're meant to fit inside the display bezel. Yikes. The SD card holder have the same height as the neoprene lining in the front cover (even with an SD card in them. I don't think it touches the screen.

[Gallo]

I going to purchase a case for my new TX. On previous Palms, I usually go with the Rhinoskin but have concerns that the case may interfere with WIFI.

Does anyone have any experiance with an aluminum case and Tungsten TX WIFI?

Thanks,
David

[jough]

Okay, I'm sold. Ordering a black Convertac case tonight.

[Guatiao]

I going to purchase a case for my new TX. On previous Palms, I usually go with the Rhinoskin but have concerns that the case may interfere with WIFI.

Does anyone have any experiance with an aluminum case and Tungsten TX WIFI?

Thanks,
David

I am using a T5 case with my T|X, and so far I have not noticed any interference with wifi. The case is a bit slippery though...

[technical1]

jough & any other covertech users:

Does the case fold back completely like the Palm T5 case?

I found the hard cases for my old T3 that didn't fold all the way back to be a bit clumsy when opening to do some work / reading while in transit on the train or whatever.

However, the black case seems way cool.

TIA,

[snark]

Does the case fold back completely like the Palm T5 case? No, it doesn't. It opens at 180°.

[WildCelt]

I just bought a Rhino Skin hardcase, and really like it. I do, however, notice a difference in wifi performance, but really only on weak signals. In normal usage, (that is, sitting in the restaraunt or my living room) it worked fine. The only time I noticed a difference is if I was farther away, say in a parking lot or something... :D

[jough]

Okay, I got my Covertec case in the mail... and it's a huge piece of crap!

Worst. Case. Ever.

And it scratched my T|X a little trying to fit it in. It most definitely does NOT easily slide in and out.

The one I got also didn't come with a belt clip, and was beat up when I got it, with some dings and such in the case.

Covertec said I could return it AT MY EXPENSE. I paid $12 for shipping (from Canada) and now I have to pay another $10 to send it back?

I'm not going to be out over $20 for a case that arrived damaged.

I'm going to contact my credit card company for a chargeback. This is ridiculous.

Oh, more Covertec stupidity - the SD card holder holds the cards backwards/upside down so that the pins are exposed and the labels are hidden. It has to be the WORST way to hold the cards, since the pins are sitting out in the open and you can't see the label to see which card it is. Who the hell designed this thing?

I'm now going to have to go back through the 1src archives so I can see who recommended this case and know not to trust anything they recommend again. No one who has ever used this case would recommend it.

Well, back to the drawing board.

Has anyone used the Boxwave Active Case?

[redriderback]

I own that black Covertec case.
I am highly stisfied with it.
It didn't scratch my Palm.
And yes, the SD card is upside down - I don't care.
I would buy it again .... and I would recommend it again.

So you see: two people, two cases and two opinions.

[jough]

You're on my list, dude. ;)

Well, to each his own. You may not care that the sensitive pins of your SD cards are exposed, or that you can't tell one card from another when they're in the case, since you can't see the label, but surely you don't think it's well-designed, do you?

I mean, you have to know that it's bad, right?

[redriderback]

I only have 1 card extra in my case, .... so no prob.
Having the case built that way, the SD cards are in the 'correct' way, would probably have resulted in the chance to more easily scratch the display. Could be?

Bad? Any bulky leather case with a huge snap-closure is IMHO bad.

[snark]

I own that black Covertec case.
I am highly stisfied with it.
It didn't scratch my Palm.
And yes, the SD card is upside down - I don't care. I agree with this.

The SD card was also upside down with my Proporta T3 alu case. I can't think of an alu case that holds the SD card with the label visible. Maybe an issue with the height of the holder.

The fact that it had scratches when you go it, I don't know why, mine arrive in pristine condition. And it didn't scratch my TX at all.

I agree that they could have included the belt clip, however. But we never said it was included! http://www.1src.com/forums/images/smilie/images/smilies/wink.gif

[antong]

I've always gone caseless, but after a mishap on my old pda :( I decided to get some cover this time. the hard cases see too bulky to me, so I finally decided to try the boxwave flexiskin. I should get it on monday, and I can report back if there is any interest...

[cmhbob]

Well, this whole case thing is starting to annoy me.

Every case I've ever had has been a flip case. I had a Rhodiana (http://www.rhodiana.com/products/pda/pda.html) for my III- and V-series, then went to a Kensington (http://www.cmishop.com/store/ShowDetails.asp?txtProductName=62200-BX&txtMfgPartNo=62200&nCategorySubID=125&txtSiteTrack=FG) hard case for my m515.

I really like having the flip-up case, and haven't been overwhelmed with any of the hard cases I've seen here yet. They all look effective, but not what I want. I think I want the case to open to the right, which would put the front on the bottom in landscape mode, and I think that would be better.

Then after antong's post, I went to boxwave's site, and found their Active Case (http://www.boxwave.com/products/activecase/active-case-palm-tungsten-t5_771.htm), which looks pretty interesting. Has anyone used any clear cases from anyone yet? The only thing I don't like about it is the total lack of padding. but it still looks like it would protect it from scratches and such. I like the belt clip as well.

Thoughts/comments?

[antong]

I have not used the Boxwave active case

but

I have recieved my FlexiSkin from boxwave. Overall, I guess I am happy with it. I guess I expected it to fit skin tight, kind of like a wet suit. The fit is fine, just not 'tight'. I am very happy with the button response. The case covers the buttons, but has molded buttons to correspond to the real buttons, and I have had no problems, (but I dont play action games, so I cant comment on that type of responsiveness).

There is a cutout on the bottom for the sync/charge cables. The pen has a little cut out as well. The top is completely open. There is a vent on the back I assume for heat, and a few holes for the speaker as well.

I like the silicon - rubber feeling when I hold the unit. No s

The screen cover is a hard plastic, which looks very clear and I have no problem reading the screen through the cover. I will have to wait and see if it gets scratched up over time. It snaps nicely into place, so there is no flopping of the cover when closed. It is completely removable, so you can use the case with out the screen cover. *** I forgot to mention, the plasitc cover does not fold flat out of the way. You can remove it, or leave it flipped up. ***

It came with a strap, (like a camera strap) and a belt clip, neither of which I plan to use. The strap hole and belt clip both add a little bump to the mold of the cover, but the case itself adds very little to the size of the unit, and the TX still fits fine in my front shirt pocket.

I suspect this cover will help protect my TX from scratches and minor dings. I will not do any drop tests though.

the price was $30 + $4.50 shipping.

[dbett]

I like the Sena flip top leather case for the TX. It's not too bulky but still protects the screen. It also has cut outs for the headphone jack, buttons (including reset button), and the hotsync/power connector.

They even added a mesh hole for the speaker.

Nice case - although it's not cheap.

[DaveSebring]

pick your poison, i guess. scratched but 'beautiful' palm or clear protector sheet and no scratched screen. i

get mine on easily and once in a blue mood have to deal with a bubble.

ebrichter

All right it's all your fault ! (in a good way).

I bought a Boxwave cleartouch screen protector.... and I am hooked (just need to build a clean room to install the thing)...

THIS is a good screen protector, all the others I have tried (ok 2-3 ) were SO STICKY that it almost pulled the LCD out of the case taking it off & on trying to get it on straight.

The Boxwave is really outstanding, the sticky side is more "tacky" than really sticky, more like a 3m sticky note than a sticker. It's very easy to remove but stays put once it's on & it's WASHABLE !!

Only took me twice to get it on with very few lint fibres and a bubble or two (which disappear by morning or sooner).

And as an added bonus the stylus feels much better on the screen with it on.

Overall I am very happy with it.

Thanks ebrichter,

[cmhbob]

Those who got the Covertec aluminum case:

Did you get a belt clip with it? I didn't, and I didn't see anywhere on their site where you could order one separately. I thought the clip and button came with the case.

Sent them an email early Monday AM, but haven't heard back from them.

[jough]

No belt clip here either. And mine arrived all beat to hell. They said they'd only do an exchange if I paid for postage both ways (another $20 out of my pocket) and were supposed to send me an RMA for a return but never did.

I just contacted my credit card company and am getting a chargeback for the whole amount. I'll probably just throw the thing out. I wouldn't want to even give this piece of crap to someone else. I have too much respect for my fellow T|X users to do that to them.

[larock]

I tried the RhinoSkin Aluminum case but didn't like how the T/X swung out of it and it seemed to limit the WiFi reception a little. I really like the soft rubber/silicone cases that I have used in the past but didn't like how Boxwave's didn't have any screen protection. So I was very happy when I found a skin case on eBay that was exactly what I wanted (CAPDASE is the brand). I think I paid just under $20 including the shipping from Hong Kong.

[antong]

I have the boxwave flexiskin cover for my TX, and it does come with a cover for the screen. Actually, it looks nearly identical to the capdase case I found on line. I dont know which is better, they seem very similar.

http://www.capdase.com/index.php?page=product&case=addToCart&type=9&cat=10&brand=41&prd=1276&pic=

http://www.boxwave.com/products/flexiskin/flexiskin-palm-tx_789.htm

[Jeff Charles]

...So I was very happy when I found a skin case on eBay that was exactly what I wanted (CAPDASE is the brand). I think I paid just under $20 including the shipping from Hong Kong.

I also just ordered a CAPDASE case on ebay, but it hasn't arrived yet. From the pictures, it differs from the Boxwave and a number of others in that the top is closed so you have to slide the TX in through the screen opening. Also, there is a protective flap covering the connector openings on the bottom.

I do have a concern that the top cover will make it harder to turn the TX on using the on/off button. If you have received yours, have you found this to be the case?

[larock]

I do have a concern that the top cover will make it harder to turn the TX on using the on/off button. If you have received yours, have you found this to be the case?

I haven't found it harder to use the on/off button. None of the pictures on the CAPDASE website show the top of the case, but there are cut-outs for the stylus silo, the on/off button and the SD memory card.

[Jeff Charles]

I haven't found it harder to use the on/off button. None of the pictures on the CAPDASE website show the top of the case, but there are cut-outs for the stylus silo, the on/off button and the SD memory card.

Thanks.

There are pictures of the top of the case on the Vinko's (http://www.vinko.com/php/shop/ebaylisting.php?shop_item_sku=C0312&shop_item_amount=13.13&shop_item_currency=usd&shop_item_usd=13.129010856&shop_item_quantity=11) website and also on their ebay pages.

[StuGib]

I was just about to order the Covertec black aluminium case when I saw your post - I did a search for slip cases and came up with www.thepouch.com or www.thepouch.co.uk for Europe. Black neoprene case with hard flip cover for $30/£20. Never tried one and can't find any reviews but the form factor is tempting me, though not being able to carry SD cards is a downside.


Sorry to revive an old post, but didn't want anyone else in the UK having to deal with this company on my conscience :mad:

I ordered a TX case on 4th November. Supposed to take 14-28 days to be delivered as they're made and shipped from the US parent company. 3 weeks later and no sign of my order on their tracking website so I rang to chase - they'd lost my order (despite me having e-mail confirmation). Ok, these things happen - I think it's the kind of case I want, so I'll wait. Told there's a slight downtime for Thanksgiving so it should be delivered within 7-10 days. I'm STILL WAITING (12th Jan). It's been 'in transit' (i.e. made and waiting to be shipped from US) since mid-December, but they've admitted they haven't had a shipment since Xmas. Cancelling the order if it's not here within a week.

So, expecting to be let down again, are people happy with the black Covertec case two months on?

Stuart

[jough]

The Covertec case is the worst case I've ever seen. The side clamps are sharp and can easily scratch the TX, the case doesn't close securely, and the SD card holder in the lid is upside down so you can't see which card is which when you put the SD cards in there (plus the pins are exposed whenever the case is open).

They would not accept a return, so I had to file a complaint with my credit card to get my money back. What a nightmare.

[lweisbrod]

I got the Covertec case a while ago, used it for a week, and haven't touched it since. The workmanship was cheap, the metal seemed flimsy, and the TX did not seem secure it in. It does not hotsync in a cradle (though I haven't found a case that does either).
I got an EB leather case subsequently, which at least has a quality feel to it.

[murrayalex]

I had a T5 and bought a few cases for it, mainly becuase I wasn't happy with most of them. I liked the pdair case best, I picked this up cheaply on ebay, mainly because the T5 slid in, wasn't too tight and came out again easily without getting scratched. I think this is an important issue with cases - how easy is it to get the pda out? I also bought the palmone T5 case - pooh, this case was poor, the T5 went in on a slider and wobbled about like Pamela Anderson's breasts in a loose fitting t-shirt. I soon dispensed with that one. I then got the proporta crystal clear case which I liked using best but it was marked down on the fact trying to get the damn thing out again felt like you'd just gone 10 rounds with Mike Tyson. I then tried a leather case I think from proporta again...didn't like this at all, it looked like something you would take to church and was a bit flimsy. All these cases of course fit the T/X...and I've just bought one so looks like it's back on the case hunt again !!

[dexor]

Waiting for my TX and checking the hard case issues; I've been using innopocket hard case on my TJ37 - but I wonder if anyone has opinions about Boxwave metal case for TX, and which one would be better - Boxwave or Innopocket?
http://www.boxwave.com/products/armorcase/armor-case-palm-tx_789.htm

[ramonaquimby]

hey, guys!

(1) if i order the case from the dude in hong kong, will i be charged some kind of duty fees or something? it says that he's not responsible for htem, which is fine, but how do i even find out if i will be a victim of these hidden charges? i'd be ordering from virginia. anyone who's ordered one have any input?

(2) is the covertec hardcase the same as this one from innopocket (http://www.innopocket.com/web/showProductDetail.asp?ID=172&name=Metal-Case-for-Palm-Tungsten-T5/TX-(Black)&code=PE-0312-B2) ? ...i've had my eye on this one for a LOOOOONG time, but jsut too chicken to jump in and make "one" decision on a freakin' PDA case. do you think it's the same? i just love how 'molded' it is...[**sigh**]

(3) any comments on this other one by pocketsolutions (http://www.thepocketsolution.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Product_Code=PSI-1848&Category_Code=METAL-PDA-CASES&Product_Count=3) ?

i'm very new to this Palm/PDA type thing, and can't get over all the choices! :eek:

[palmbot]

I bought the Black Innopocket Aluminum Case for My T|X from Alpinetop for $18.95

Even though Alpinetop is in Canada the item was shipped from Hong Kong so I am not sure if its the same "dude" from Hong Kong that ramonaquimby was referring to but I wasn't charged a hidden fee.

I think its a great case -- it has 2 SD card slots.

The $18.95 is a sale price according to their site which is good until the 11th. Otherwise its $24.90.

Alpinetop is also a powerseller on ebay where you should also be able to buy this case.

The web site for the case is here:

http://www.alpinetop.com/p/10001735/Palm-TX/Innopocket-Aluminum-Metal-Hard-Case---Black/InnoPocket-Palm-Tungsten-T5---TX-Metal-Deluxe-Case---Black.html

[mechael]

I’ve never used a metal case before, and I just bought a TX, so I wanted to get a good protection for it. I’m looking for a metal case that can fold the cover 360° so I can hold it firmly in my left hand when I’m using it on the street. Most of the cases including the Rhino case and the Covertec case only opens 180°, while most leather case can fold the cover back. I want the protection of metal case, but I really fear that when I’m trying to balance the slippery metal case opened on my hand, I’d drop the whole thing to the ground (so much for a metal case protection!). Can anybody give me any hands-on experience of how easy to hold the thing while it’s opened 180°? Also, other than the Palm T5 case, which was known to be a piece of crap, is there any other metal case that opens 360°? Thanks.

[p_boucher]

Ok time to bring back this thing up!

Also bought an Innopocket from AlpineTop.
- The shipping you pay is it, not more charges. Shipped Airmail from HK.

I've never seen a metal case that store SD card label facing you. It's the way the cards are made that make the storage clip this way. Look at it closely. Anyway.

My main gripe with the Innopocket is that the case could have been slimmer! There's a good 3-4mm extra space at the top and in depth. Probably the T5 is a little bigger than the T|X and companies did not made cases to fit exactly the TX. So the Palm "floats" freely inside. That I don't like.

It's quite a nice case but I like a snuggier fit. Any other suggestions? Seems Covertec is out of question now :).

What about PDAir and Boxwave?

[buckeyetex315]

I’ve never used a metal case before, and I just bought a TX, so I wanted to get a good protection for it. I’m looking for a metal case that can fold the cover 360° so I can hold it firmly in my left hand when I’m using it on the street. Most of the cases including the Rhino case and the Covertec case only opens 180°, while most leather case can fold the cover back. I want the protection of metal case, but I really fear that when I’m trying to balance the slippery metal case opened on my hand, I’d drop the whole thing to the ground (so much for a metal case protection!). Can anybody give me any hands-on experience of how easy to hold the thing while it’s opened 180°? Also, other than the Palm T5 case, which was known to be a piece of crap, is there any other metal case that opens 360°? Thanks.


I have the Rhino Skin hard case for my TX. It only opens 180 degrees, but that is okay with me. I can hold the case in my left hand with my thumb on the lining just to the left of the hinge and my other fingers underneath the right side for support. It actually balances pretty well. The hinge seems strong enough to use this way. I have not seen any flexing or other problems with the lids or the hinge. This hold also gives me good control over the TX. Hope this helps.

[buckeyetex315]

I've never seen a metal case that store SD card label facing you. It's the way the cards are made that make the storage clip this way. Look at it closely. Anyway.


I agree on the SD card issue. In fact, many of the hard cases look very similar to me. Only minor cosmetic changes like the clasp, logo, maybe the hinge or a cutout. Look at RhinoSkin, InnoPockets, PocketSolutions, BoxWave. All probably made by the same manufacturer in China.


My main gripe with the Innopocket is that the case could have been slimmer! There's a good 3-4mm extra space at the top and in depth. Probably the T5 is a little bigger than the T|X and companies did not made cases to fit exactly the TX. So the Palm "floats" freely inside. That I don't like.

It's quite a nice case but I like a snuggier fit. Any other suggestions? Seems Covertec is out of question now :).

What about PDAir and Boxwave?

My RhinoSkin hard case is the same way - loose fit inside the case. Otherwise I like the case really well.

Reason - they're probably all the same case - see answer above.
Solution? - I think I'll try buying some of those stick on felt circle pads you can put on the bottom of vases, etc to not scratch tables. Just a couple of small (1/4 " ones) in the outside corners of the lid might do the trick....

Edit: Sorry - accidentally deleted a bracket and slash mark....