Aquapac vs. Otterbox 3800

[NJL!2016]

How good will both these cases do at, lets say...the beach? Does anyone own one of these cases? I have a Otterbox 3600 which is good for my SJ-22 but it seems like my upcoming SJ-33 will not fit because of the hinge at the top. I also like the Aquapac because it is MUCH cheaper than the Otterbox 3800. So, i'm kinda leaning for an Aquapac. Any suggestions?

[jv1]

I do not own that particular Otterbox but I do own other Otterboxes. I would not change. The one I have for my digital camera when I go fishing has been underwater lots of times. It has never failed me.

[notmuch]

Do you need the case to be crush-proof?
Yes: Otterbox
No: Aquapac

[NJL!2016]

Yea, I really don't need crushproof. I just need one for a day at the beach or by my pool. I think that the Aquapac is a good choice